Rule Hub · DrivingUS requirements, state by state

No-Fault Does Not Mean Nobody Is at Fault

Updated September 22, 2026

“No-fault” is one of the worst-named ideas in American insurance law. It does not mean fault stops mattering, it does not mean nobody is blamed, and it does not mean you cannot be sued. It means something much narrower: your own insurer pays your own economic losses first, whoever caused the crash, and in exchange your right to sue the other driver is restricted rather than removed.

As of this article’s 22 September 2026 update, the state pages on this site record four states as running that system — Florida, Massachusetts, Michigan and New York — and two, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, as Choice. Every other state page records an ordinary tort state, where the at-fault driver’s liability insurer pays.

The two halves of a no-fault system

Every no-fault state has to answer two questions, and they are independent of each other.

How much does your own insurer pay? That is the personal injury protection limit.

When are you allowed to step outside the system and sue? That is the tort threshold.

New York answers the first with $50,000 of “basic economic loss” per person — medical and related expenses, lost earnings up to $2,000 a month for three years, and other reasonable expenses up to $25 a day for one year. It answers the second with the “serious injury” threshold in Insurance Law § 5102(d): you may sue for pain and suffering only if the injury clears it. See New York’s fault page.

Florida answers the first with $10,000 in medical and disability benefits plus $5,000 in death benefits — and with a limit inside the limit, since medical benefits are capped at $2,500 if a qualified provider determines there was no emergency medical condition. It answers the second with a four-part test in § 627.737(2): significant and permanent loss of an important bodily function, permanent injury, significant and permanent scarring or disfigurement, or death. Under § 627.737(1) an insured driver is exempt from tort liability for bodily injury to the extent PIP benefits are payable. See Florida’s fault page.

Massachusetts answers the first with at least $8,000 per person — medical and funeral expenses, 75% of average weekly wage, and replacement services, incurred within two years of the accident — and the at-fault driver is exempt from tort liability to that extent. PIP pays no more than $2,000 of medical expenses that health insurance covers, and the policyholder may buy a PIP deductible, from $100 up to $8,000, that applies to the policyholder and household members. It answers the second partly with a number: you can sue for pain and suffering only if reasonable medical expenses exceed $2,000, or the injury causes death, loss of a body member, permanent and serious disfigurement, certain loss of sight or hearing, or a fracture. See Massachusetts’s fault page.

Those three states have fixed answers. Michigan does not.

Michigan lets the driver set the ceiling

Since 2 July 2020, PIP medical is still mandatory in Michigan, but the insured picks the limit from six options:

  1. Unlimited.
  2. $500,000 per person per accident.
  3. $250,000.
  4. $250,000 with PIP-medical exclusions for household members who hold qualified health coverage.
  5. $50,000 — available only if the named insured is enrolled in Medicaid and every spouse and resident relative has qualified health coverage, Medicaid, or PIP under another auto policy.
  6. Opt out of PIP medical entirely — available only if the named insured has Medicare Parts A and B and every spouse and resident relative has qualified health coverage or PIP under another auto policy.

If no valid selection is made, the policy defaults to unlimited. Wage loss, replacement services, and survivor’s and funeral benefits stay on the policy even under a full opt-out.

Options 5 and 6 are gated, not offered. “Qualified health coverage” means a plan that does not exclude or limit auto accident injuries and whose annual individual deductible sits at or below a figure the Department of Insurance and Financial Services indexes each July 1 — $6,579 for 1 July 2026 through 30 June 2027. A health plan that fails either test does not qualify, and the election that depended on it is not available.

The practical result is that there is no single statutory PIP number in Michigan. $250,000 is the lowest limit a driver with ordinary health coverage may select, $50,000 is reachable only by a Medicaid enrollee, and a Medicare Parts A and B enrollee may carry no PIP medical at all. See Michigan’s minimums.

Why that election changes who pays

This is the part that is easy to miss, and it is the reason the Michigan choice is not a private matter between a driver and their own policy.

When every Michigan policy carried unlimited PIP, an injured person’s allowable expenses and work loss were covered by their own insurer, full stop. Since 2 July 2020, when each driver began electing a ceiling, an at-fault driver can be sued for the injured person’s allowable expenses and work loss above that cap — or without limit where the injured person opted out of PIP medical entirely. That exposure did not exist before 2020, and it is the practical reason the default bodily injury limits were raised to 250/500 at the same time.

So one driver’s decision to buy a $50,000 PIP limit creates liability exposure for whoever hits them. The two halves of the reform were designed together.

What survives in Michigan besides PIP

Michigan abolishes tort liability except for the exceptions in MCL 500.3135(3). Two are worth knowing.

The mini-tort is the one most drivers meet: for crashes after 1 July 2020, a driver 50% or more at fault can be sued for up to $3,000 of vehicle damage insurance did not cover — usually the other driver’s collision deductible. The cap was $1,000 for earlier crashes. These claims go to small claims or district court.

Property Protection Insurance is mandatory and unique to Michigan. It pays up to $1,000,000, without regard to fault, for damage your car does to buildings, fences and properly parked vehicles inside Michigan. It does not pay for damage to another moving car.

Two Michigan-specific bars also cut the other way: a person injured while driving their own uninsured vehicle recovers nothing in tort, and mini-tort damages are not awarded for a vehicle that was being operated without the required security.

New Jersey and Pennsylvania: the policyholder picks the threshold

Both states are recorded here as Choice. In each, first-party medical coverage is mandatory whatever the policyholder elects; what is chosen is how far the right to sue is restricted. The two states set the default in opposite directions.

New Jersey is a no-fault state with a choice of lawsuit option. Personal injury protection is mandatory on both Standard and Basic policies. On a Standard policy, $250,000 of medical expense benefits applies unless you choose a lower limit in writing; the lowest you may select is $15,000 per person per accident, and even at that limit up to $250,000 is payable for permanent or significant brain injury, spinal cord injury or disfigurement, and for certain trauma-center care. The Basic policy’s PIP is also $15,000.

The lawsuit election is separate. A Standard policyholder picks either Limitation on Lawsuit — no suit for pain and suffering unless the injury is death, dismemberment, significant disfigurement or scarring, a displaced fracture, loss of a fetus, or a permanent injury — or No Limitation on Lawsuit. If you do not choose in writing you get the limitation, and Basic policyholders always have it. See New Jersey’s fault page.

Pennsylvania works the other way round. It requires first-party coverage — it calls it “medical benefits” rather than PIP — with a minimum limit of $5,000, and it is mandatory regardless of anything else. Higher limits, and separate extraordinary medical benefits above $100,000, are available.

What the policyholder elects is the tort option. Limited tort keeps your right to recover out-of-pocket medical and other expenses but gives up damages for pain and suffering except where the injury meets an exception in the law. Full tort keeps that right unrestricted. If you do not specially elect limited tort, you are deemed to have chosen full tort.

That election, made once when the policy is bought, usually decides more about a Pennsylvania claim than any other single term on it. See Pennsylvania’s fault page.

PIP is not the same thing as no-fault

A PIP line on a policy does not make a state no-fault. Maryland, Texas and Washington each carry PIP of some kind, and each is recorded as an ordinary tort state.

Maryland requires PIP unless the first named insured waives it in writing, and it pays your own medical bills and lost wages up to $2,500 regardless of fault. But the driver who caused the crash still pays for the other side’s losses, and the PIP insurer has no right to recover what it paid from the at-fault driver. See Maryland’s fault page.

Texas includes PIP in every policy unless you reject it in writing, with a statutory minimum of $2,500 per person. Washington only requires insurers to offer it: the minimum package is $10,000 of medical and hospital benefits, it can be rejected in writing, and it is optional coverage rather than a no-fault substitute for a liability claim. In none of the three is your right to sue the other driver restricted by the PIP you carry.

Where fault comes back

In every one of these states, fault returns the moment a claim leaves the first-party system. The comparative negligence rule then governs everything claimed from the other driver — which is a separate question, handled on the fault rules page.

Look up your state