Rule Hub · DrivingUS requirements, state by state

The One Percentage Point That Decides Your Claim

Updated September 22, 2026

Everyone knows the rough idea: if you were partly to blame for a crash, you get less. What almost nobody knows is that “how much less” is decided by a rule that changes at the state line, and that in some states the answer is “all of it.”

Here is what the states covered on this site actually do.

Four rules, not one

Rule What happens States
Pure contributory Any fault at all, even 1%, bars recovery entirely Maryland, North Carolina, Virginia
50% bar You recover nothing at 50% or more Georgia, Tennessee
51% bar You recover nothing above 50% Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Massachusetts, Michigan, New Jersey, Ohio, Texas, Wisconsin, New York (car crashes)
Pure comparative Your share of fault reduces your recovery but does not bar it Arizona, California, Missouri, Washington

Pennsylvania is not in the table. That is deliberate.

Read the middle two rows again, because the difference between them is a single percentage point and it is worth the entire claim.

Exactly 50% is the fault line

Imagine the same crash, same facts, and a jury that splits the blame down the middle: you 50%, the other driver 50%.

Same crash. Same jury finding. In one state you collect, in the other you go home with nothing.

The 51% bar states do not all phrase the test the same way. Ohio and Indiana compare your fault with the combined fault of everyone else; New Jersey and Wisconsin compare it with the party you are suing, and Wisconsin makes that comparison separately against each defendant. The page for each state quotes its own wording.

Three states where any fault ends the claim

North Carolina, Maryland and Virginia keep pure contributory negligence. If you bear any share of the blame at all — one percent — your claim is over. Not reduced. Over. There is no 51% bar and no reduction of damages in proportion to fault: it is all or nothing. Very few states still work this way.

A driver who was speeding slightly while someone ran a red light into them can lose entirely.

The three states arrive at the same result from different sources, and each has its own details:

If you drive in any of these three states, this single rule matters more than any coverage limit on your policy, because it decides whether the other driver’s insurance pays you anything at all. See the fault pages for North Carolina, Maryland and Virginia.

Pure comparative: no cut-off at all

At the other end, Arizona, California, Missouri and Washington never bar a claim for the claimant’s own fault. Damages are reduced by your share, so a driver found 90% at fault still recovers the remaining 10%.

Here too the source differs. Arizona (A.R.S. § 12-2505) and Washington (RCW 4.22.005) set the rule by statute. Missouri’s comes from the Missouri Supreme Court in Gustafson v. Benda (1983); the Missouri statute that writes pure comparative fault down, RSMo § 537.765, covers only product liability claims. California’s is stated in its civil jury instructions (CACI No. 405), citing Li v. Yellow Cab Co. (1975).

Florida used to be on this list. HB 837 (ch. 2023-15) added § 768.81(6): a party found more than 50% at fault for their own harm recovers nothing. Before March 24, 2023, Florida was a pure comparative state where a claimant 90% at fault could still recover 10% of their damages.

New York changed on May 26, 2026

Before May 26, 2026, New York was a pure comparative state for car crashes — you recovered no matter how much of the blame you carried, just reduced by your share.

Part EE of the FY2027 budget bill (S.9008-C, chapter 58 of 2026) added subsection (b) to CPLR 1411, effective May 26, 2026: in a personal injury action subject to Insurance Law article 51 — which is to say, most car crash claims — a claimant whose culpable conduct is greater than the defendant’s is barred entirely.

So New York runs two rules at once. Car crash claims get the 51% bar. Everything else keeps pure comparative under CPLR 1411(a). The same budget part also directs that the fact-finder decide fault before deciding whether an injury is a “serious injury”. Guides that describe New York as a flat pure comparative state are describing the law as it stood before May 26, 2026.

No-fault does not mean this stops mattering

Florida, Massachusetts, Michigan and New York are no-fault states, and New Jersey and Pennsylvania are choice states, where the policyholder picks how far they give up the right to sue. It is easy to assume comparative negligence is irrelevant when your own insurer pays your medical bills regardless of blame.

It is not. No-fault governs your own benefits. The moment your injuries clear the threshold that lets you step outside the no-fault system and sue the other driver — in Massachusetts, for example, reasonable medical expenses over $2,000, or an injury such as a fracture — you are in tort, and the comparative rule applies to everything you are claiming from them. Michigan makes this especially visible: its 51% bar is written specifically against noneconomic damages — the pain and suffering piece that no-fault benefits never covered in the first place.

Pennsylvania: a deliberate blank

You will notice Pennsylvania is missing from the table. That is not an oversight.

Pennsylvania’s comparative negligence rule lives in its consolidated statutes, and every official Pennsylvania host for that text was unreachable when we checked in September 2026. We do not publish figures we have not read at their source, so the field is empty on the Pennsylvania fault page rather than filled with a number copied from a secondary site.

Pennsylvania has its own wrinkle regardless: it is a choice state, where the policyholder elects full tort or limited tort when they buy the policy. That election — not the comparative rule — is usually the thing that decides whether a Pennsylvania driver can claim for pain and suffering at all.

What this means in practice

  1. Your state’s rule is not your neighbour state’s rule. A crash three miles across a border can be governed by a completely different regime.
  2. “Partly at fault” is not a settled quantity. It is argued, and in a 50% bar or contributory state the argument is about whether you get everything or nothing, not about a percentage.
  3. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage matters more in strict states. If the rule can zero out your claim against the other driver, the coverage you bought yourself is what is left.

Every state page on this site carries the rule for that state with the source it comes from, and the date we last checked it. Start with your own: all states.

Look up your state